"Veteran experimental filmmakers Danielle Huillet and Jean-Marie Straub helmed this unusual adaptation of a novel by Elio Vittorini. Focused on the triumphs and failures of a group of laborers and farm hands who pooled their resources to operate an alternative collective farm after the end of World War II, Operai, Contadini features a cast of 12 actors who read aloud from Vittorini's book for the duration of the film, either reciting from memory or using a clearly visible script. Hardly designed to be a crowd pleaser, Operai, Contadini proved to be controversial among the audiences for its showings at the 2001 Cannes Film Festival, where it was screened as part of the Directors' Fortnight series." ~ Mark Deming, All Movie Guide
"The group makes up a primitive community which seeks to erase not only the distress created by the war but also the hardships of life and hunger, and to protect them from violence, misery and fear. Amid the ruins of this post-war period, the characters build and invent a rapport both in their professional and daily lives between themselves, the sexes, generations, diverse social and geographical origins, and antagonistic political camps.
The group maintains a 'register', a kind of diary, as if it were entering the minutes of an inquiry or a trial." -Steve Grayson
"my favorite Straub-Huillet films are Too Early, Too Late and Operai, contadini (2001), both color landscape films with especially acute senses of place as well as of nature in all its harsh beauty." - Jonathan Rosenbaum
肯定是不如原版的，黄政民演黄政民，只能证明电梯战神丁青是本色出演。其他的，没啥好说的！
6.5分。说是翻拍《解救吾先生》，但其实就是解了个壳。整个电影少了太多原作里的那种博弈和智斗戏码，变成了部简单的韩式动作片了。黄政民自己演自己本来是个非常好的噱头，但没太多发挥演技的空间，也就随便看看吧。
为什么不是绑架马东锡呢？说实话没有刘德华那个版本好看。
黄政民完全没有什么表演，所以是导演还是剧本的错。结尾的The Passenger亮了
跟原版不太一样，剧情不合理，人物都很蠢，除了大明星以外。
这个中韩翻拍项目下所有的片子都是严重水土不服
这TM不完爆原版么！电梯战神黄政民的演技。
还有一丝丝做作与刻意
没有原版拍得好 独居老人那段太鸡肋 另 和黄政民一起被绑架的玩过鱿鱼游戏的妹子李瑜美为啥没有名字
把原来一部斗智斗勇的警匪片，生生改成了血糊糊惨兮兮警匪死了一箩筐的动作片。
黄政民演这种角色的确是信手拈来，只是通篇没什么惊喜，而且看过综艺发现其实黄政民本人是比较腼腆的，有点出戏
冲着黄政民看这部翻拍片的。有些地方太过了，有些地方不够到位。还是原版好！
影片翻拍自2015年刘德华、刘烨、王千源、吴若甫主演的《解救吾先生》
翻拍了一个寂寞，这波我天朝完胜，吾先生的优点在王千源，人质的缺点在黄政民，不是他不好，而是他演了自己且没有跟他匹配的对手戏演员，韩国版把重点放在众匪，祸起萧墙的阶级感深入骨髓。
整体节奏很紧凑，不过最后部分的剧情设置太中二了！
可惜他们应该展开后面的故事也许会好一些，但是没有也许
黄政民是我最喜欢的韩国演员，人家国家演员演啥像啥，咋们国家的娘炮演啥不像啥，吃啥啥不剩
黄政民自己演自己，演的真像啊→_→沉醉着迷了
整体节奏很紧凑，不过最后部分的剧情设置太中二了！
打斗戏手铐的桥段和老手如出一辙…
Copyright © 2015-2023 All Rights Reserved
